By Chris Seiter

Published on August 15th, 2022

Today we’re going to talk about if exes ever come back to you after dating someone new.

Like most things in the breakup industry there is a short answer and a long answer to this.

Really quick, here’s the short answer;

It is definitely possible for an ex to come back to you after dating someone new but certain conditions need to be present,

  • You have a better chance if your ex is an avoidant
  • Rebound relationship honeymoon period addiction
  • You probably will have needed to use some form of the being there method
  • Your ex will probably need to have painted you as a “phantom ex”

There’s a lot to talk about here.

Let’s begin

What Are Your Chances of Getting Your Ex Boyfriend Back?

Take the quiz

You Have A Better Chance Of This Occurring If Your Ex Is An Avoidant

Initially this may seem like an odd take. Anyone who knows even a little bit about attachment styles can surely argue that avoidants tend to value their own independence over everything else.

However, our internal research has consistently shown that most of our clients end up dating people who are avoidant.

To the tune of 70% actually. This means that most of the research I’ve done over the past decade has been on understanding how avoidants operate.

Last year I filmed a video called, How To Make Your Avoidant Ex Miss You,

In it I essentially argue that,

Avoidants are free to long for an ex once that person is unavailable out of the relationship, and typically out of contact so they are untouched by actual engagement and their deactivation systems aren’t triggered, revealing their long-suppressed attachment and switching their operating attachment wound from the fear of engulfment to fear of abandonment.

So, three things need to happen in order for an avoidant to even consider “going out” with you again.

  • You need to have done something to indicate you have moved on
  • They need to have moved on (we will dig into this later I promise)
  • Enough time needs to have gone by that the sting of the breakup isn’t affecting them as much anymore

Here’s the thing about avoidants. Their M.O. is all about independence so it shouldn’t come as a shock that they begin having nostalgia based feelings when they also have their independence back.

But there seems to be a flaw in that thinking, right?

How can they feel independent if they are with someone else?

Great question. I think the best way to look at avoidants in relationships is that they are addicted to honeymoon periods.

The Rebound Relationship Honeymoon Period Addiction

This is what the typical relationship life cycle looks like for an avoidant,

I’ve been through this so many times on dozens of articles so I don’t really feel like repeating it but to be really quick about it here are the eight stages that avoidants go through from the beginning to the end of a relationship,

  1. The avoidant wants someone to love them
  2. They enter into a relationship with you
  3. They notice some worrying things in the relationship
  4. They think of leaving you
  5. They actually leave you
  6. They are happy they left you
  7. They begin to feel kind of lonely
  8. They wonder why they can’t ever find anyone

The stage that’s of interest to us is this one,

What Are Your Chances of Getting Your Ex Boyfriend Back?

Take the quiz

The depression part where they wonder why they can’t find anyone for them. That’s the most important thing to conceptualize because it really explains WHY avoidants actually can go on the rebound.

And really if you look at the whole death wheel above one thing becomes very clear. Avoidants live for the honeymoon period.

It’s soon enough into the lifecycle of a relationship that not a huge commitment is needed and obviously you are feeling great.

Yet the moment a relationship gets more serious. The moment independence becomes threatened they begin to work their way out of the relationship.

So, really the way I’ve always viewed avoidants is that they are constantly chasing the “high” of a honeymoon period and this is a really great distraction tool so they don’t have to deal with the complicated emotions that surface on the onset of a breakup.

That brings us very nicely back to that light green section on the upper left-hand quadrant of the death wheel.

An avoidant will do everything to stave off this stage. Once it begins to set in they will find ways to distract themselves (usually with other people) which really explains why they are going from relationship to relationship chasing the distraction of the high.

You Probably Need To Be Painted As A Phantom Ex

So, let’s play devils advocate here.

Your ex is on the rebound with someone else but you have a strong belief that your relationship was more impactful.

  • You were with your ex longer
  • You were more serious than they were

If that’s the case then you might be a good candidate for being painted as a phantom ex.

I define the phantom ex as,

A past partner that you can’t seem to stop thinking about. Instead, you hyper focus on them and romanticize your time together. Even when that time together wasn’t all that great.

From an avoidant perspective this is like hitting the jackpot. Remember, an avoidant is constantly living this balancing act where they want love but they refuse to let anyone close enough to them to receive that love.

Often their solution to fixing this paradox is to find a phantom ex.

A partner that they can fawn over from afar without the threat of losing their independence.

But there’s something really interesting about this phenomenon. Inevitably it fails, especially when they are on the rebound.

So, here’s what usually happens.

  • Your ex moves on to someone new to chase a new honeymoon period
  • They do this so they don’t have to deal with the grief of their breakup with you
  • In order to ensure they don’t feel threatened by their rebound they paint you as a phantom ex
  • This keeps them far enough away both from their current relationship and their old one
  • But the longer they keep this scenario the more the new person they are with gets annoyed or triggered
  • Comparing the ideal version of you (the phantom version) to the actual rebound is no contest
  • They start preferring this ideal version of you and ultimately break up with their new partner
  • Nostalgia has begun to kick in and sometimes they want to revisit that with you

This is often how most of our success stories have occurred where another person was involved but there is another big piece of the puzzle I’m leaving out.

How The Being There Method Fits Into This All

The being there method is essentially the spearpoint that helps you attract an ex back who has gone on the rebound.

Here’s how it works,

Basically the theory behind is revolves around attachment styles.

What Are Your Chances of Getting Your Ex Boyfriend Back?

Take the quiz

There are four major attachment styles,

  1. Secure
  2. Anxious
  3. Avoidant
  4. Fearful

All of the attachment styles have an interesting relationship with the secure attachment style in the fact that it’s an attachment game changer.

Throughout our lives based on our experiences our attachment styles can change.

Take an insecure attachment style like an avoidant and partner that person with a secure attachment style and an interesting phenomenon can occur.

The avoidant attachment style can actually begin to change and become more secure themselves. Of course, the opposite can also happen,

The secure attachment style can get worn down by the avoidants insecurities and become more insecure themselves so what really unfolds with every relationship is an attachment battle,

Pretty wild, right?

So, all the being there method really is, is you becoming more secure and staying in contact with your ex. That’s it. You aren’t trying to win them back. You aren’t trying to break them and their new partner up. You are just going to be there.

You are going to let your secure attachment do the work for you.

And what happens is usually twofold.

  1. Your presence triggers the rebounds insecurities which in turn causes your avoidant ex to be triggered
  2. Your constant presence causes your ex to subconsciously paint you in the phantom ex role

Now, in the spirit of honesty I will say that the being there method can be a bit morally grey. Some people will not feel comfortable using it.

But the core principles remain sound.

Work on making your attachment style more secure and you will reap the benefits not only with your ex but in other areas of your life.

What to Read Next

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

7 thoughts on “Do Exes Ever Come Back After Dating Someone New?”

  1. Luis

    August 4, 2024 at 3:23 pm

    Hey, so my gf broke up with me we left on good terms. We still love each other and she was telling me that her heart would always be mine and that we need to heal first before coming back together again. But she said she wanted to get back into dating new people eventually and that every person has their own way of healing so I’m really confused.
    There was a lot in the relationship. Way too much hurt and arguments, I was really insecure I made her cry a lot and treated her bad, she was also really insecure and always got mad about the littlest things all the time but on the other hand we loved each other so hard, even tho all the fights we would always come back amazing and loving each other again hard. This time was different I was still insecure and I realized too late she made up her mind and left for good she’s already talking to new guys which I believe she moved on prior to the breakup she’s done this before but we were able to talk it out and tried to work it out but this time was different I could see that there’s no going back I do understand with everything I put her thru. We said a last goodbye in person huged each other, cried, she said it was too late for us to work it out. I called later that night, talked, she said she was also thinking about calling me bc she miss when we would call every night to sleep. she also said she wants to heal in her own way, but she would always wait for me and that she’s really confused on what she wants and that she’s gonna miss me and still loved me very much and that her heart would always be mine. There’s so much more to it our relationship was really like no other it was different I could speak all day about it. Do you think still we can reconcile ?

  2. Clark

    November 20, 2023 at 5:54 am

    I went on a no contact rule with my ex gf for about a week or so but not a month is it still possible I can get her back?

    1. Coach Shaunna

      November 20, 2023 at 1:34 pm

      Hi Clark, no you would need to complete a 30 day NC to give you both space and time away from each other

  3. Sylvia

    November 13, 2023 at 6:18 am

    I’m in the process of being there. I don’t know if I messed up. He asked for advice with his gf and asked me to talk to her. I did. Granted he seemed to be watching me and not her more while I talked to her but , I don’t know if I overdid the be there friendly bit or not. Any thoughts

    1. Coach Shaunna

      January 2, 2024 at 2:04 am

      Hi Sylvia, so the point of the being there method is that he is comparing you to her the entire time, you coming out on top in what he looks for in a partner. Speaking with her and being friendly does go in your favour to an extent, but your goal is not to be HER friend.

  4. Samantha

    August 22, 2022 at 1:37 pm

    Hi!

    My ex broke it off almost a year ago. It wasn’t a long term thing, but we were together for a little under a year, with zero fights and a great time. He broke it off because he had doubts about us, after a lot of back and forth.

    We have barely stayed in touch since (I backed off immidiently). Long story short, we ran into each other a few weeks ago and he offered to catch-up. We had a really nice time, after a lot of laughing he got serious and said it was really good to see me.

    He then later asked if I was seeing someone. I kept it simple and said only “casual things”. I was forced to ask the question back, not to make it seem awkward. He revealed, uncomfortable, that he was dating someone. I stayed upbeat and smiling. He then added that it was “just a couple of months and we’ll see how the future goes”… which I found bizarre. Since we parted after that, he texted the next day to say how nice it was seeing me and how he hoped we could do it again. I responded kindly, and we exchanged a few songs.

    I am unclear on my next move. Should I ask him to do something? Or back-off until he does, because he is seeing someone? The catch-up was 4 days ago, he has yet to respond to my last text (which was a simple response to his), which was 2 days ago.

    I would love to have him back in my life, taking it slow, and seeing if we can patch things up (or stick to friendship).

    Thanks!

    1. Coach Shaunna Nicol

      September 2, 2022 at 10:04 pm

      Hey Samantha, so if you want him back as in a relationship then yes see him again and keep going. I would suggest that you read this article about the being there method while h is dating someone else and has made you aware, you need to be sure that when you do meet up that you are pushing more flirty than friendly.

      https://www.exboyfriendrecovery.com/exactly-how-the-being-there-method-works/